A Creationist Cliche and that Berkeley Study

There's a common Creationist cliche that Darwinists can't really trust the workings of their minds on the grounds that those workings were caused by evolution instead by a God-given ability to discern the Truth.

That cliche does not apply very well to Darwinism. After all, an animal can evolve to be able to identify true statements. A pigeon's mind can tell the truth about bread crumbs; a cat's mind can tell the truth about mice; and a human's mind can tell the truth about cause and effect.

The cliche does apply to theories that purport to explain away other people's ideas instead of considering reasons or evidence (seen via Dissecting Leftism).